Apologies if I'm incorrect, but, shouldn't there be 7 shields left in the Halloween raid instead of 8? I know MM said in his RP that his character didn't break a shield, only cracked it, but that doesn't seem to be in line with what's written in the raid rules, i.e. a cheer removes one shield. Maybe I'm mistaken here, but I'm under the impression that whomever is calculating the damage and shields is going to count his cheer as a shield break, leaving us with 7 shields at the time of your posting.
